Computer Hardware

Home Entertainment

Forum

Find Lowest Prices

About Us

Contact Us

Our Reviews

Computer Hardware 

AMD A10-6800K Review ....................

Antec ISK110 VESA Case Review .............................. ....................

Antec P280 Case and HCP1200 PSU ....................

Intel Ivy Bridge i7-3770K CPU

Fujifilm FinePix HS20EXR Camera

AMD Radeon HD 7870

AMD Radeon HD 7770 & 7750

AMD Radeon HD 7970 .........................

AMD Bulldozer FX-8150 CPU

ASUS EAH6970 Graphics Card

AMD Llano A8-3850 Review

Cougar GX G1050 1050W PSU

Antec HCG900 900W PSU

Rasurbo Xange Case and 550W PSU ....................

Cooler Master Storm Enforcer Case ....................

AMD Phenom II X4 980BE CPU Review

AMD 6-series Entry Level GPUs

AMD ATI Radeon HD6990 Review

Intel 510 Series 250GB SSD

ASUS ENGTX580 DCUII Review

Sapphire Radeon HD6870 Vapor-X

Antec Minuet 350 Case Review

Sapphire Radeon HD6950

Intel Sandy Bridge Processors

AMD Phenom II X4 975BE & X6 1100T

AMD Phenom II X6 1090T Thuban CPU ...............

Kingston V+ Series 128GB SSD Review

Antec P183 Case and 1000W PSU

AMD ATI Radeon 5670 Review

AMD ATI Radeon HD 5850 Review

AMD Athlon II X4 630 CPU Review

Intel Lynnfield i7-870 Processor Review

Kingston DDR3 Memory Review

ASUS Maximus III Gene Motherboard

ASUS M4A79T Deluxe Motherboard

Antec Midi Tower Case and PSU

Active Media SaberTooth SSD

More Power Protection Products ......................... ...............

DDR2 Memory Roundup

Dual Layer DVD Burners Reviewed

Dual Format DVD Burner Review

QuietPC Product Roundup

GlobalWIN Product Roundup

Sapphire Radeon 9800 AIW Pro

Athlon 64 FX-51 Review

Lian Li PC37 Aluminum Mini Tower Case ...............

Abit IS7-G Motherboard Review 

AOpen AX4C Max Review

Promise S150 TX4 RAID Controller

Silent Power Supplies Reviewed

Nvidia GeForce FX5900 Ultra ....................

Promise TX4000 RAID Controller

ASUS V9900 Ultra Review

Promise TX2Plus RAID Controller

AMD Athlon XP3200+ CPU Review

Intel Canterwood Chipset Review

ASUS P4SDX Deluxe Motherboard

Dual Athlon MP2600+ Review

Pinnacle Systems: Edition DV500

Athlon XP3000+ CPU

  ..

TwinMOS Memory

 

Leadtek K7NCR18D-Pro

Aopen CRW4850 CD Burner Review

AOpen AK77-8X Max Motherboard Review

AOpen AX4PE Max Motherboard Review

Enlight Cases Roundup

Power Protection Products Review

Creative Webcam Pro eX Review

PAPST Fans (Silent PC Part2)

AMD Athlon XP2700+ CPU

Leadtek WinFast A280 MyVIVO

Crucial PC2700 DDR333 Memory

Chieftec Wireless Desktop Review

Intel Pentium4 3.06GHz CPU with Hyper Threading Review

Hyper-Threading Technology Guide

PURE Digital SonicXplosion Sound Card

PURE Digital ZXR-500 Speaker System

Logitech Z-560 4.1-Speaker System

Global Win GAT-001 Case Review ....................

Intel Pentium 4 2.8GHz Review

Belkin Omniview 4-Pt. KVM Switch + Audio

AKASA Paxmate Acoustic Matting Installation Guide

Chieftec Winner Series: WX-01BD Case Review ..........

Cooler Master ATC-710 Case Review

80mm -> 60mm Fan Adapter

TDK USB Bluetooth Adaptor

Socket-A Cooler Roundup 

Promise FastTrak SX4000 RAID Card

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dual Format DVD Burners 24th December 2004

Just in time for Christmas we are able to review two of the latest Dual Layer drives to become available. Both write to single layer DVDs at 16-speed and dual later DVDs at 4-speed. We managed to find some Verbatim 2.4x DVD+R DL disks (courtesy of Verbatim) which quite happily write at 4x without problem. 16-speed blank DVDs are becoming available but DL DVDs will be scarce (and expensive) for some time.

 

 

Introduction

 

The LiteOn drive came in a retail pack but the NEC one was a bare drive. The NEC lacks a front headphone connector but few people use these so it's no great loss. 

 

 

The LiteOn is shorter (almost standard on  LiteOn drives now) which may be useful when space is tight. Otherwise both drives have the usual rear connectors etc.

 

 

 

LiteOn SOHW-1653S 

 

The LiteOn came in a nice retail pack.

 

 

This includes Nero and PowerDVD which are great to get started straight away.

 

 

NEC ND-3500A

 

The NEC model was a bare drive so we cannot say for sure what would be included in a retail pack but looking at its siblings it can be reasonably expected to be at least as good as the LiteOn offering.

 

 

Feature Comparison

 

Feature

Drive

 

Lite-On

SOHW-1653S

NEC

ND-3500A

 

 

Read:-

 

CD-R

Yes

48X

Yes   48X 

CD-RW

Yes

-

Yes   -  

DVD-RAM

No

-

No -  

DVD-ROM

Yes

16X

Yes   16X 

DVD-R

Yes

-

Yes   -  

DVD-RW

Yes

-

Yes   -  

DVD+R

Yes

-

Yes   -  

DVD+RW

Yes

-

Yes   -  

DVD+R DL

Yes

-

Yes   -  

CD Text

Yes

-

Yes   -  

CD+G

Yes

-

Yes   -  

C2 Errors

Yes

-

Yes   -  

 

Write:-

 

CD-R

Yes

48X

Yes   48X 

CD-RW

Yes

24X

Yes   24X 

DVD-RAM

No

-

No  -

DVD-R

Yes

16X

Yes   16X 

DVD-RW

Yes

4X

Yes   4X 

DVD+R

Yes

8X

Yes   8

DVD+RW

Yes

4X

Yes   4X 

DVD+R DL

Yes

4X

Yes   4X 

Mount Rainer

No

-

No -  

Buffer Underrun Protection

Yes

-

Yes   -

Buffer

Yes

2MB

Yes   2MB  

 

Bundled Software

Sonic MyDVD

Bare Drive

Power DVD

 

Cables Supplied

IDE & Audio

Bare Drive

Blank Media Supplied

8X DVD+R

2.4X Dual Layer DVD-R

Bare Drive

           

 

 

Test Results

 

   

For this and all other tests we will stick to the following order: NEC ND-3500A on the left and LiteOn SOHW-1653S on the right. 

Nero's information utility shows all the features at a glance and is a useful comparison to see what the drives can and cannot do. Full size screen captures can be displayed by clicking on the above images. All drives are Region locked (RPC-2) and would require a custom BIOS to be flashed to become RPC-1. Naturally this would void the warranty and may leave a drive completely inoperative and so is a risky venture.

Both the NEC and the LiteOn can write to CDs at 48x  and both drives have a 2MB buffer. Although we would like to see larger buffers as write speeds increase, it seems the inclusion of BURN-proof technology has made coasters much harder to create due to a brief hiccup in the data stream. Sustained interruptions can still ruin a DVD burn as part of the capacity of a disk is used up each time Buffer Under run is employed.

Each drive was flashed to the latest BIOS for maximum compatibility with media and in both cases this was done from within Windows XP and did not require a DOS boot-up making the process a painless one even for novice PC users. After this the drives were tested with a range of media and found to be compatible with all of them. For the testing we decided on Princo 8x DVD-R disks as we had several cake boxes of these lying around and Verbatim 2.4x DL disks (writing at 4x). We started by burning a 4.7GB ISO image at 16x with Nero 6 and timed the results. Then we used an 8GB ISO with Nero 6 to test dual layer burning and timed those results as well. The are summarized in the following table.

 

 

Drive Media Time Taken
LiteOn SOHW-1653S Single Layer 9 Minutes 22 Seconds
LiteOn SOHW-1653S Dual Layer Failed
     
NEC ND-2500 Single Layer 9 Minutes 53 Seconds
NEC ND-2500 Dual Layer 25 Minutes 58 Seconds

 

There was a problem burning at DL with the LiteOn drive and we got the following message:

 

After retrying we concluded that the drive was faulty but were not able to get a replacement in time for this review.

No errors were reported during the burning process but that does not necessarily mean the disks were perfect (readers who have relied on successful completion messages in the past only to find read errors at a later date will know to take these messages with a pinch of salt). It is a well known fact that writing at a slower speed makes for more reliable disks so how well can data be read back?

 

   

The graphs show that both drives were able to read back the disks with no glitches but the NEC drive won easily in terms of speed.

 

Due to the inability of the LiteOn to successfully burn at DL we can only show the result for the NEC drive which coped very well without glitches. The symmetrical shape of the graph is characteristic of DL disks and there was no noticeable pause when switching layers.

Since the test was performed on a 3.2GHz P4 the CPU usage figures should be taken with a pinch of salt and our CPU usage never went beyond 2-3% during the burning process for any of the drives.

Now we come to another important issue. If DVDs do not suffer from DVD rot (still only isolated incidents so far) they should last a lifetime. During that time it is unlikely they will always be accessed on the drives used for recording and so the question of reliably reading the disks in other drives becomes important. It is wrong to assume that disks recorded in one drive will play back equally well in other models and in particular stand alone DVD players.

Read tests were performed with the previously burned disks in a Pioneer DVD-106 DVD-ROM drive with the following results.

 

   

The LiteOn burned DVD refused to be recognized correctly let alone allow data access. The NEC burned disk read back flawlesly.

 

Once again we cannot provide a result for the LiteOn drive but the NEC drive produced disks which could be played without problem in any DVD-ROM drive or DVD player.

 

 

 

Conclusion

 

It's a shame the LiteOn drive developed a fault during testing and we hope to update this review when we get our hands on a working one. The NEC 3500A is a superb drive and can be picked up for around 50 in many places. It is much faster than its predecessor at ripping DVDs and finally removes the need to have a separate DVD-ROM drive (previously DVD writers tended to be much slower at reading disks).

Although Dual Layer disks are still scarce there is no reason not to buy a Dual Layer burner like the NEC 3500A as the price premium over as Single Layer burner is negligible and a small prce to pay for future peace of mind. Consumers will also be pleased to know that recordings made at full speed (16x) play back flawlessly and there is no need to use a lower speed for those "precious DVDs". We would still recommend any special occasions (weddings etc.) burned onto DVD to be done at least twice and disks kept separately until more is known about the phenomena of DVD rot.

We would like to thank LiteOn and Plextor for providing the necessary review samples.  We would also like to thank Verbatim Europe for providing High Quality Double Layer DVD Media for our tests.

 

All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

Custom Search

 

    Celebrity Pictures